How Painting Increases Your Home's Value

Jun 18, 2025

Whether you're preparing to sell or simply want to enhance your property’s worth, a fresh coat of paint is one of the most cost-effective ways to boost your home’s value. Studies show that professional painting can increase a home’s resale value by 3-5% on average, with some cases seeing returns of 10% or more depending on the market and quality of work.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore:
✔ How painting affects home value (interior vs. exterior)
✔ The best paint colors for resale (backed by real estate data)
✔ Real-world examples of homes that sold for more after painting
✔ Color Psychology

How Much Does Painting Increase Home Value?

Exterior Painting: The First Impression That Sells Homes

A home’s exterior is its first impression, and buyers often judge a property within seconds. According to a National Association of Realtors (NAR) report:
• 94% of realtors recommend exterior painting before listing
• Fresh exterior paint can add 2-5% to a home’s sale price
• Homes with peeling or faded paint sell for 10-15% less in competitive markets

Real Example:
A 2023 study by Zillow found that homes with a black or charcoal gray front door sold for $6,271 more than expected.
Meanwhile, homes with a fresh white exterior sold 4-6% faster than those with outdated colors.

Interior Painting: Neutral Sells, Bold Colors Can Hurt Value

While personal style matters when living in a home, neutral tones appeal to the widest range of buyers.

Data from Sherwin-Williams & Benjamin Moore:
• Light grays, whites, and beiges help homes sell faster and for more money
• Bold or dark colors (like red or navy) can reduce offers by 5-10%
• Professionally painted interiors see a 72% ROI (Remodeling Magazine’s Cost vs. Value Report)

Case study:
A Chicago townhome sat on the market for 4 months with dark accent walls.
After repainting in Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray, it sold in 2 weeks for $12,000 over asking.

Best Paint Colors for Resale (Interior & Exterior)

Exterior Paint Colors That Increase Value

Interior Paint Colors Buyers Love

• Walls: Agreeable Gray (SW 7029) – warm neutral
• Trim: Pure White (SW 7005) – crisp contrast
• Kitchens: Alabaster (SW 7008) – bright & clean
• Bathrooms: Sea Salt (SW 6204) – spa-like feel

Pro Tip: If you love bold colors, use them in small doses (accent walls, furniture) rather than full rooms.

Real Estate Case Studies: How Strategic Painting Transformed Home Values

Painting isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s a strategic investment that can dramatically impact a home’s sale price and time on the market. Below, we dive into three real-world examples where professional painting made the difference between a stagnant listing and a bidding war.

Case Study 1: The $25,000 Paint Job That Sold a Home in 11 Days

Location: Austin, Texas

Before:
• A 1990s ranch-style home with a faded yellow exterior and outdated dark brown trim.
• Interior walls were a mix of bold reds and deep blues, turning off potential buyers.
• The home sat on the market for 4 months with no offers.

The Fix:
• Exterior: Repainted in Sherwin-Williams Shoji White (a warm, modern neutral) with Iron Ore (SW 7069) accents.
• Interior: All walls repainted in Repose Gray (SW 7015), with Pure White (SW 7005) trim for contrast.
• Cost: $6,200 (including pressure washing and minor repairs).

The Result:
• 11 days on market after repainting.
• 5 competing offers, sold for $25,000 over the original asking price.
• Appraisal came in $18,000 higher than pre-paint estimates.

Why It Worked:
• Neutral colors broadened buyer appeal (young families and investors both loved it).
• Fresh exterior paint signaled a well-maintained home, justifying a higher price.

Case Study 2: The Quick Flip That Doubled Its ROI

Location: Denver, Colorado

Property: A 1980s condo in a competitive downtown area.
Before:
• Dingy off-white walls with scuff marks and outdated wood paneling in the living room.
• Cabinets were a dark, dated stain, making the space feel small.

The Fix:
• Walls: Repainted in Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace (a bright, clean white).
• Cabinets: Painted *Hale Navy (BM HC-154)* for a modern contrast.
• Cost: $3,500 (labor + materials).

The Result:
• Listed one week after painting.
• Sold for $8,000 more than identical units in the building.
• ROI: 128% (more than doubled the investment).

Why It Worked:
• Light walls made the space feel larger and brighter (crucial for small condos).
• Navy cabinets added a touch of luxury without overwhelming buyers.

Case Study 3: The "Unsalable" Home That Sparked a Bidding War

Location: Portland, Oregon

Before:
• A 1930s Craftsman home with dark purple walls and peeling exterior paint.
• Feedback from buyers: "Too much work," "Feels gloomy."
• Price reduced twice, still no offers after 3 months.

The Fix:
• Exterior: Repainted in Benjamin Moore White Dove (a soft, historic-friendly white).
• Interior: All walls repainted in *Edgecomb Gray (BM HC-173)*, a warm neutral.
• Cost: $7,800 (including exterior prep work).

The Result:
• 7 offers within 5 days of relisting.
• Sold for $18,000 over the revised asking price.
• Final sale price was 6% higher than pre-paint appraisals.

Why It Worked:
• Neutralizing the colors removed buyer objections.
• The fresh exterior boosted curb appeal, attracting more foot traffic.

The Psychology of Paint: How Color Influences Buyer Decisions

Few home improvements have as much psychological power as paint. Color doesn’t just change how a home looks—it changes how buyers feel about it. Studies in real estate psychology and neuromarketing reveal why certain colors command higher offers, while others scare buyers away.

A. The "Move-In Ready" Effect: Why Buyers Pay a Premium

Key Finding: 87% of buyers prefer homes that don’t require immediate work (National Association of Realtors, 2024).

• The Brain Science:
◦ When buyers see peeling paint or bold colors, their brain registers "work required", triggering stress.
◦ Fresh neutral paint signals "move-in ready", activating the brain’s reward center.

• Real-World Impact:
◦ A 2023 Zillow study found that homes needing paint sold for 7% less than identical, freshly painted homes.
◦ In competitive markets (like OKC’s hottest neighborhoods), this gap widens to 10%+.

Pro Tip: Even if your home has older systems (roof, HVAC), fresh paint creates a "well-maintained illusion" that boosts perceived value.

B. Color Psychology: What Each Hue Says to Buyers

Case Study: A University of Texas study tested two identical homes—one with red walls, one with light gray. The gray home received 28% more offers and sold 17 days faster.

C. The "First Impression" Power of Exterior Paint

Buyers decide within 7 seconds if they’re interested in a home based on its exterior (Journal of Real Estate Research).

• Winning Exterior Color Combos:
◦ White + Black Trim = +5% perceived value (2024 Zillow Paint Study)
◦ Light Gray + Navy Door = +$4,600 sale premium
◦ Sage Green + White Trim = "Trustworthy, eco-friendly" vibe

• Losing Colors:
◦ Peeling Paint = -15% offers (signals neglect)
◦ Bright Yellow = -22% showings (too polarizing)

Real Example: A Seattle home painted "Sherwin-Williams Naval" (dark blue) sat unsold for months. After repainting Alabaster White, it sold in 9 days with multiple offers.

D. The "Halo Effect": How Paint Distorts Other Perceptions

Fresh paint creates a cognitive bias where buyers assume:
✅ "If they painted, they probably maintained the roof/plumbing too."
✅ "This home is newer than it actually is."

Data Proof:
• A Florida State University study found that buyers estimated freshly painted homes to be 5-8 years newer than their actual age.
• Homes with peeling exterior paint were assumed to need $18,000+ in hidden repairs—even if inspection proved otherwise.

E. Gender & Generational Color Preferences

• Women prefer warmer neutrals (beige, cream) by a 3:1 margin (Sherwin-Williams survey).
• Men respond best to crisp contrasts (white trim on gray walls).
• Millennials love moody accents (deep green cabinets, black doors).
• Baby Boomers favor traditional whites/taupes.

Strategy: If selling in a family neighborhood (like Edmond), lean into warm neutrals. For urban OKC condos, modern grays perform better.

Final thought

Painting isn’t just maintenance—it’s behavioral science. The right colors don’t just hide flaws; they manipulate buyer emotions to command higher prices.

Ready for a Fresh, Affordable Interior Paint Job?

📍 Proudly serving Oklahoma City, Edmond, Norman, Moore, Newcastle, Bethany, Yukon, Mustang